Monogamy and cheating

I was reading Doonesbury yesterday and the cartoon pointed out the hypocrisy of certain Republican candidates for the presidential nomination. Between three of the leading Republican candidates, there are five divorces, "four really messy and all involving adultery."

Why do we retain monogamy as our dominant culture ideal when even those who most staunchly support it don't live by it? Why instead don't we teach a loving, honest and open polyamory as the ideal?

__________________________

...because public space really matters!

Elizabeth

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Why not teach polyamory as an ideal?

I go back and forth about this all the time!
I think monogamy is a kind of... artificial (?) condition.  I've been trying to maintain an open relationship for about two years based on that principle:  it's natural for us to be attracted to other people and it's not wrong to act on it, but in a relationship our sexual decisions necessarily affect both partners, so that has to be taken into consideration.
Sometimes it works, but working out the details takes a lot of discussion, sometimes argument.
So we're trying to train ourselves in the ideals of openness, but we're no more equipped for that than we are to be exclusive, and I often ask myself whether it wouldn't be easier to default to monogamy just to minimize the conflict.  ; )
I'd love to hear from others who have more success maintaining variations on conventional relationships!

Mongamy as an Ideal

I think that it's a bad idea to replace one default model with another. The problem with our current mono-focused society is that monogamy is presented as THE one-size-fits-all solution to relationships, and it's so obviously not. But poly takes a lot of balancing and juggling, too, and doesn't suit everyone at all times. It's important to be able to look at the different needs of relationships through their evolution and be able to have more than one solution.
__________________________

Blog: Literate Perversions

“Writing is like prostitution. First you do it for love, and then for a few close friends, and then finally y

Playing Mono-poly

I agree that it's the universal application and expectation of monogamy that's a problem. There are circumstances that I can see monogamy as a good choice. Poly, in my very limited experience, does take an enormous amount of effort and commitment. Not just from you, but the group together, which is hard. It's like being in a rock band or something. When you have a demanding career or kids (or both) the effort you'd apply to being in poly tribe, for all of its appeal, can seem like too much.

There is no single ideal

I'd have to agree that there's no need to promote any particular arrangement as the "ideal," but instead allow people to explore whatever solution is best for them.

Monogamy has always come easy to me. Now that I'm married with children, my biggest concern is not whether or not my husband is sexually faithful to me, but negotiating a balance regarding childcare, housework, social life and family income. Sometimes I'd be happy to let my husband get sex elsewhere once in a while just so I can catch up on my sleep;) But if he were to be spending his time outside the home with someone else, I would have to pick up the slack at home and that's what would make me resentful.

I love the idea of polyamory in theory, but I think that in practice it would be very challenging. It's taken me years to find one man that I'm compatible with on every level. I feel incredibly lucky to be so well-matched, and I'm a little doubtful that I'm going to run into many other people who could fit that bill. AND taking on another lover would mean that person would have to be compatible with both of us, which narrows the field even further.

Still, I'd like to be open to that possibility. The idea of a sister-wife actually has some appeal, and so does a brother-husband:) It's just that my standards are very high and we have a lot of family obligations already. It wouldn't seem fair to expect a third lover to take on the responsibilities of our family, nor would it be fair for either myself or my husband to divert our energies outside the home anymore than we already do. It's already a delicate balance but we manage it remarkably well.


__________________________

Talk dirty to me.

polyamory as an ideal

Polyamory is a poor choice for an ideal, since it barely works for its tiny number of adherents. Monogamy, for all its problems, has a long track record, with huge segments of the world successfully following it. Polyamory is like any other alternative lifestyle, it works for a minority of people and should be encouraged, but it hardly qualifies as "the answer."
__________________________

Tom Paine
author of "Polyamorously Perverse"
http://perverselypoly.blogspot.com/

It's hard to know if it would work...

I wonder if one reason it is so difficult to make polyamory work is that we are so ill-prepared to try it. What I mean is that all of our cultural training is for monogamy. Our institutions support monogamy rather than nonmonogamy, so it isn't any wonder that monogamy works for more people. I wonder how many people polyamory or other nonmonogamous options would work for if those were also supported culturally and by our institutions.

(I'm headed over to the thread Tom_Paine just started to take up the question of replacing one limiting ideal with another.)


__________________________

...because public space really matters!

Elizabeth

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <br /> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options